152 Comments

  1. Hello,

    Do you use salted or unsalted butter? Thanks!

    1. Author

      Hi Alyssa,
      You can use either one for this recipe.

  2. Hi, I was wondering about the yield of this recipe?

    1. Author

      Hi, depending on how thick your cookies are, at least three dozen cookies.

  3. Mine are in the oven baking as I type = ) we are having our first ever ‘bake off’ at work so i’m hoping these impress the judges. Thanks for the easy to follow recipe.

  4. Thanks a lot! I’ll make these cookies this week!

  5. Hi
    How many cookies will there be made?

    1. Author

      Hi Ira,
      It depends on how thick you slice the cookies, about 3 dozen.

  6. hi,ive made this using your recipe and it was lovely,my favourite cookie. however i have a question,i want to make again and im out of butter just margerine.id i substitute butter dor margerine will it affect the final taste as i love the taste i got the last time and cant wait till i buy butter to try again.

    1. Author

      Hi, yes, you can use margarine as a substitute.

  7. Hiya,
    I don’t have a mixer of any sorts so I used my hands and they turned out great! I just had to work the dough in a bit more than usual. I also refrigerated the dough before I rolled it out and that helped. I love this recipe because I’m only 13 but still found it nice and easy! = )

    1. Author

      Hi Danica,
      That’s great! Thanks for the note.

      1. Hi there..i tried your recipe..it was awesome..pinwheels had always been a challenge for me..but u made it easy for me..thanks..i love ur site..

        1. Author

          Glad to know and thanks for the feedback, Sumaira!

  8. These came out beautifully!

    Both of the doughs were pretty soft (especially the chocolate one), so I chilled everything between each step & rolled the half balls out between 2 sheets of waxed paper.

    Fairly labor intensive, but I took my time between stages & that worked fine. Now I’ve got 30 impressive looking cookies & another roll in the freezer to slice & bake whenever I need them.

    Many thanks!

  9. I want to try this cookies, can i replace egg with something else? As we don’t eat egg, thanks

    1. Author

      Hi Sharma,
      You can try omitting the egg yolks, but I haven’t tried doing that, so I’m not so sure how that would turn out.

  10. Hello…first time here.

    These cookies drew me in because I have yet to make this variety of pinwheel.
    I’m willing to give your recipe a try. I already have a few flavour ideas to explore with.

    I do however have an important question? Do you measure your flour as spoon and level or scoop in and level. This particular matter seems to usually make or break most recipes I’ve tried in the past.
    BTW, I’m the spoon and level kind of baker ;o)

    Lovely web site…looking forward to have time to look around some more.

    Happy holidays,
    Claudia

    1. Author

      Hi Claudia,
      I measure flour by spooning the flour into the cup and leveling. I don’t dip the measuring cup and scoop out the flour.
      Thanks for the note and happy holidays to you too!

  11. I just made these for my family’s Christmas dinner, and they were a huge hit! Thank you so much = )

    1. Author

      Hi Alice,
      That’s great! Thanks for the feedback.

  12. just made these, beautiful result thank you for sharing them =)

    1. Author

      Hi Ruth,
      Thanks for the feedback! Hope you enjoyed making them.

  13. These came out so delicious! I am not a confident cook/baker and thought there was no way mine would come out looking like the pictures, but to my surprise they did!! I will be making these for all the staff at my son’s preschool. Thank you!!

    1. Author

      Hi Aimee,
      I appreciate the feedback!

  14. Hi! =) Just wanted to THANK YOU for this amazing recipe! I’ve done these cookies twice already and everyone loves them! You have done an amazing job with explaining everything – even for a non-native English speaker (I’m Croatian). So, THANK YOU! I’ll be back, for sure, to re-do these and even try the ”pink version”!
    Have an amazing day,
    Anđela

    1. Author

      Hi Andela,
      Thank you for the feedback!

  15. Wow…. Such a lovely invented cookies…

    1. Author

      Hi Rithu,
      Thanks!

  16. I doubled the recipe by making the dough twice and adding chocolate to one complete batch of dough and making the other batch split into red and green dough…I wish I could post a picture. ..thwy look so Christmassy

    1. Author

      Hi Loralee,
      Thanks for the awesome idea!

  17. Hi,
    I was wondering if I want to add peanut butter to the cookie, how should I adjust the recipe?
    Looking forward to trying the recipe! It looks so awesome! <3
    Thank you~

    1. Author

      Hi Bee,
      I haven’t tried adding peanut butter to the recipe. If I get a chance, I’ll try to make a batch with peanut butter and let you know how it turns out.
      Thanks!

  18. Hi! How far ahead of an event can I bake these without compromising taste?
    Thanks ahead = )

    1. Author

      Hi Loulwa,
      Once you have the cookie dough rolled into pinwheel logs, you can freeze them up to weeks ahead of time. Then bake the cookies just when you need them.

      1. Thanks so much for replying. I ended up having lots of fun with making the cookies with different shapes and colours =) I froze the cookies since monday and baked them today (friday) and i put them in my daughter’s birthday giveaway bags for her friends to take home. I hope they taste fine by then! =) I would have shared pics if this form let me!

        Thanks again. Great recipe!

        1. Author

          Hi Loulwa,
          Glad to hear!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *